Working paper: Private regulation, freedom of expression and journalism: Towards a European approach?

Bili?, meningitis Paško (2011): How Social Media Enforce Glocalisation – the Processes of Identity Change in Selected Central and Southeast European countries. In Milohni?, population health A. & Švob-?oki?, ask N. (eds): Cultural  Identity Politics in the (Post-)Transitional Societies. Culturelink/IMO: Zagreb

Cafaggi Fabrizio & Casarosa Federica (2012): Private Regulation, Freedom of Expression and Journalism: Towards a European Approach? EUI Working Papers, Law 2012/20. Available at: http://www.mediadem.eliamep.gr/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/WP-LAW-2012-20.pdf

Craufurd Smith, Rachael (2009): Media Ownership and the Public Interest:  The Case of Virgin Media, British Sky Broadcasting and its ITV Shares. The Journal of Media Law (1), 21-37

Craufurd Smith, Rachael (2008): Balancing Culture and Competition: State Support for Film and Television in European Community Law. Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies (10), 35-66

Craufurd Smith, Rachael (2007): Media Convergence and the Regulation of Audiovisual Content: Is the European Community’s Audiovisual Media Services Directive Fit for Purpose? Current Legal Problems, 238-277

Craufurd Smith, Rachael (2007): The UNESCO Convention on the Protection and Promotion of the Diversity of Cultural Expressions: Building a New World Information and Communication Order? International Journal of Communication, 24-55

Craufurd Smith, Rachael (2006): European Community Media Regulation in a Converging Environment. In Shuibhne N.N. (ed.): Regulating the Internal Market. Edward Elgar Publishing

Craufurd Smith, Rachael (2005): Preserving and Promoting Media Pluralism and Diversity in Europe: The Role of the European Union. In Brogi, E., Vodinelic, V. and Gajin, S. (eds): Developing a Harmonized Information and Communication Law in Europe. Centre for Advanced Legal Studies: Belgrade

De la Sierra, Susana (2008): Principios y Objetivos Relacionados con el Reforzamiento de la identidad Cultural de la Comunidad Autónoma (Principles and Objectives Related to the Reinforcement of Cultural Identity of Autonomous Communities in Spain). In Balaguer Callejón F. (ed.): Reformas Estatutarias y Declarationes de Derechos 789 et seq. Tirant lo blanch/Instituto Andaluz de Administración Pública: Valencia

Docquir, Pierre-François (forthcoming, 2012): ‘Internet, les raisons d’un droit d’acce?s’. In Dubuisson F. (ed): Le te?le?chargement d’œuvres sur Internet, Actes du colloque du 14 de?cembre 2010

Docquir, Pierre-François (2011): ‘The challenges of net neutrality’. Quaderns del CAC, vol. 37

Docquir, Pierre-François (2011): ‘Le défaut manifeste de fondement et l’article 10 de la CEDH’. In Lambert-Abdelgawad E. and Dourneau-Josette P. (eds): Quel filtrage des requêtes par la Cour européenne des droits de l’homme. Ed. du Conseil de l’Europe

Docquir, Pierre-François (2011): ‘Les décisions de recevabilité concernant la Belgique’. In Lambert-Abdelgawad E. and Dourneau- Josette P. (eds): Quel filtrage des requêtes par la Cour européenne des droits de l’homme. Ed. du Conseil de l’Europe

Docquir, Pierre-François (2011): ‘L’annulation de l’interdiction de la publicité politique n’était pourtant pas nécessaire’. J.L.M.B. (11), 505

Docquir, Pierre-François (2010): ‘Réflexions sur l’efficacité des droits de l’homme’.  In Les droits de l’homme et l’efficacité de la justice – Actes du colloque de l’Association Syndicale des Magistrats. Larcier: Bruxelles

Docquir, Pierre-François (2010): ‘La seconde vie du droit: le droit dans les univers virtuels’. R.D.T.I. (40), 5-14

Docquir, Pierre-François (2010): ‘Donjons et législations, ou les avatars du droit dans les mondes virtuels’. R.D.T.I. (40), 91-101

Docquir, Pierre-François (2009): ‘N’ayons plus peur de la liberté d’expression sur Internet: à propos d’une définition stricte des ‘discours de haine’, note sous Bruxelles (12e ch.), 23 janvier 2009’. R.D.T.I. (37)

Docquir, Pierre-François (2009): ‘Protection de l’enfance dans le carnaval numérique: l’art. 8 de la CEDH impose un «devoir de démasquer» aux fournisseurs de services Internet (Note sous l’arrêt K.U. c. Finlande, du 2 déc. 2008)’. R.D.T.I. (34)

Docquir, Pierre-François (2007): Variables et Variations de la Liberté d’Expression aux Etats-Unis et en Europe. Coll. Droit & Justice, n° 72. Bruylant: Bruxelles

Docquir, Pierre-François (2007): Droit de Réponse ‘2.0’ ou la Tentation d’un Droit Subjectif d’Accès à la Tribune Médiatique. In Les Propos qui Heurtent, Choquent ou Inquiètent. Revue de Droit de l’ULB: Brussels

Fengler, Susanne & Ruß-Mohl, Stephan (2008): Journalists and Information-Attention-Markets. Journalism 9 (6), 667–690

Fengler, Susanne & Ruß-Mohl, Stephan (2008): The Crumbling Hidden Wall: Towards an Economic Theory of Journalism. Kyklos 61 (4), 520-542

Fengler, Susanne (2008): Media Journalism and the Power of Blogging Citizens. In Krogh, Torbjörn von (eds): Media Accountability Today – and Tomorrow. Göteborg: Nordicom

Fengler, Susanne & Ruß-Mohl, Stephan (2006): The Three Paradoxes of Media Journalism. In Egli von Matt, Sylvia et al. (eds): Media Journalism in the Attention Cycle – Problems, Perspectives, Visions. Lugano/Milano: Giampiero Casagrande Editore

Fengler, Susanne (2003): Holding the News Media Accountable: A Study of Media Reporters and Media Critics in the United States. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 80 (4), 818-832

Frydman, Benoît et al. (2010): Public Strategies for Internet Co-regulation in the United States, Europe and China. In Brousseau, E. & Marzouki, M, Meadel C. (eds): Governance, Regulations and Powers on the Internet. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Frydman, Benoît & Englebert, Jacques (2002): Le Contrôle Judiciaire de la Presse. Auteurs & Médias (6)

Frydman, Benoît (1997): Quel Droit pour l’Internet? In  Montero, É. (ed.): Internet Sous le Regard du Droit. Bruxelles: Editions du Jeune Barreau de Bruxelles

Fossum, John Erik & Schlesinger, Philip (eds) (2007): The European Union and the Public Sphere: A Communicative Space in the Making? London and New York: SAGE

Guichot, Emilio (ed.) (2011): Derecho de la Comunicación. Madrid: Iustel

Gusy, Christoph (2008): Pressefreiheit contra Republikschutz (Freedom of the Press versus Protection of the Republic)? In Kohl, Neschwara & Simon (eds), Festschrift für Wilhelm Brauneder zum 65. Geburtstag: Wien

Gusy, Christoph & Haupt, Heinz-Gerhard (eds) (2005): Inklusion und Partizipation – Politische Kommunikation im Historischen Wandel (Inclusion and Participation – Political Communication in its Historical Change). Frankfurt/Main

Lauk, Epp (2009):  Reflections on Changing Patterns of Journalism in the New EU Countries. Journalism Studies 10 (1), 69 – 84

Lauk, Epp (2008): How Will it All Unfold? Media Systems and Journalism Cultures in Post-Communist Countries. In Jakubowicz, K. & Sükösd, M (eds): Finding the Right Place on the Map: Central and Eastern European Media Change in Global Perspective. London: Intellect Books

Linde Paniagua, E., Vidal Beltrán, J.M., Medina González, S. (2011): Derecho Audiovisual. Madrid: Editorial Colex

Mazziotti, Giuseppe (2009): Italy. In Long, C. (ed.): Global Telecommunications Law and Practice. Sweet and Maxwell: London

Mazziotti, Giuseppe (2008): EU Digital Copyright Law and the End-User. Springer Verlag: Berlin

Milohni?, Aldo & Švob-?oki?, Nada (eds) (2011): Cultural Identity Politics in the (Post-)Transitional Societies (Part two: Communication, Media and Cultural identities). Culturelink/IMO: Zagreb

Mungiu-Pippidi, Alina (2002): From State to Public Service: The Failed Reform of State Television in Central Eastern Europe. In Sükösd, M. & Bajomi-Lázár, P. (eds): Reinventing Media: Media Policy Reform in East Central Europe. Budapest: CEU Press

Müller, Sebastian (2010): Ökonomischer und staatlicher Einfluss auf die Medien in Europa. Drei Länderbeispiele. vorgänge 49(4), 46 – 54. Available at: http://pub.uni-bielefeld.de/publication/2469084

Ondruchova, Maria (2007): Wahlkampf global (Global Election Campaigns). In Politik und Kommunikation

Peruško, Zrinjka & Popovi?, Helena (2008): Media Concentration Trends in Central and Eastern Europe. In Jakubowicz, K. & Sukosd, M. (eds): Finding the Right Place on the Map: Central and Eastern European Media Change in Global Perspective. Intellect Books: Bristol

Peruško, Zrinjka & Popovi?, Helena (2008): From Transmission to the Public Good: Media Policy for the Digital Age in Croatia. In: Sukosd, M. & Isanovi?, A. (eds): Public Service Television in the Digital Age: Strategies and Opportunities in Five South-East European Countries.  Mediacentar: Sarajevo

Popovi?, Helena & Hromadži?, Hajrudin (2008): Media Users: From Readership to Co-Creators. In Uzelac, A. & Cvjeticanin, B. (eds): The Changing Dynamics, Culturelink Joint Publication Series. Zagreb: Institute for International Relations

Primorac, Jaka & Jurlin, Kreiimir (2008): Access, Piracy and Culture: The Implications of Digitalization in Southeastern Europe. In: Uzelac, A. & Cvjeti?anin, B. (eds): Digital Culture: The Changing Dynamics, Culturelink Joint Publication Series. Zagreb: Institute for International Relations

Psychogiopoulou, Evangelia (ed.) (2012): Understanding Media Policies: A European perspective. Palgrave Macmillan

Psychogiopoulou, Evangelia (2012): State aids to the press: The EU’s perspective’. European State Aid Law Quarterly (1), 57-71

Psychogiopoulou, Evangelia (2012): Hof van Justitie van de EU, 16 February 2012, zaken C-360/10, Belgische Vereniging van Auteurs, Componisten en Uitgevers CVBA (SABAM) v Netlog NV, Noot: E. Psychogiopoulou (Case note in English). European Human Rights Cases 13 (5-18 May 2012), 931-939

Psychogiopoulou, Evangelia (2011): Hof van Justitie van de EU, 22 September 2011, zaken C-244/10 en C-245/10, Mesopotamia Broadcast A/S METV en Roj TV A/A tegen Duitsland, Noot (Case note in English). European Human Rights Cases 12 (12-17 December), 1857-1869

Psychogiopoulou, Evangelia (2010): The ‘Cultural’ Criterion in the European Commission’s Assessment of State-Aids to the Audio-Visual Sector. Legal Issues of Economic Integration (37), 273-91

Psychogiopoulou, Evangelia (2008): The Integration of Cultural Considerations in EU Law and Policies. Martinus NIjhoff Publishers: Brill

Psychogiopoulou, Evangelia (2006): EC State Aid Control and Cultural Justifications. Legal Issues of Economic Integration 33 (1), 3-38

Rorive, Isabelle & Frydman, Benoît (2002): Regulating Internet Content through Intermediaries in Europe and the USA. Zeitschrift für Rechtssoziologie. Max Planck Institute

Rorive, Isabelle (2003): Strategies to Tackle Racism and Xenophobia on the Internet – Where are We in Europe? International Journal of Communications Law and Policy, 7. Available at: http://www.ijclp.net/ijclp_web-doc_8-7-2003.html

Schlesinger, Philip (2009): Cultural and Communications Policy and the Stateless Nation. Catalan Journal of Communication & Cultural Studies 1(1), 9-14

Schlesinger, Philip (2009): Creativity and the Experts: New Labour, Think Tanks and the Policy Process’. International Journal of Press Politics 14(3), 3-20

Schlesinger, Philip (2007): La Nación y Espacio Comunicativo. In Lila Luchessi & María Graciela Rodriguez (eds): Fronteras Globales: Cultura, Política y Medios de Comunicacíon. Buenos Aires: La Crujía

Schlesinger, Philip (1991): Media, State and Nation. London: Sage

Schulz, Wolfgang (2009): The Legal Framework for Public Service Broadcasting after the German State Aid Case: Procrustean Bed or Hammock? Journal of Media Law 1 (2), 219-241

Schulz, Wolfgang (2008): Kommentierung zu Art. 10 EMRK und Art. 5 GG. In Berlit W, Meyer C and Paschke M (eds.): Hamburger Kommentar zum gesamten Medienrecht. Baden-Baden

Schulz, Wolfgang (2008): Medienkonvergenz light – Zur neuen Europäischen Richtlinie über audiovisuelle Mediendienste [Media Convergence Light – on the New European Directives on Audiovisual Media Services]. EuZW

Schulz, Wolfgang, Held, Thorsten & Laudien, Arne (2005): Suchmaschinen als Gatekeeper in der öffentlichen Kommunikation. Berlin

Schulz, Wolfgang & Held, Thorsten (2004): Regulated Self-regulation as a Form of Modern Government. An Analysis of Case Studies from Media and Telecommunications Law. Eastleigh

Schulz, Wolfgang & Ziewitz, Malte (2004): Extending the Access Obligation to EPGs and Service Platforms? In Closs, W. & Nikolzchev S. (eds): Regulating Access to Digital Television. Strasbourg

Schulz, Wolfgang (2003): Aufmerksamkeit für die “Res Publica” im Zeitalter der Vernetzung: vom Leitbild der integrativen Gesamtöffentlichkeit zur Koordination situativer Themenöffentlichkeiten. In Ladeur K.-H. (ed): Innovationsoffene Regulierung des Internet: Neues Recht für Kommunikationsnetzwerke. Baden-Baden

Schulz, Wolfgang, Held, Thorsten & Kops, Manfred (2001): Von der dualen Rundfunkordnung zur dienstespezifisch diversifizierten Informationsordnung? Baden-Baden

Skolkay, Andrej (2010): Media Law in Slovakia. Kluwer Publishers

Skolkay Andrej (2009): Media and Globalisation. Bratislava: School of Communication and Media

Sözeri, Ceren & Güney, Zeynep (2011): Türkiye’de Medyan?n Ekonomi Politi?i: Sektör Analizi [The Political Economy of the Media in Turkey: A Sectoral Analysis]. TESEV Publication: Istanbul. Available at: http://www.tesev.org.tr/UD_OBJS/PDF/DEMP/ENG/11461ENGmedya2WEB21_09_11.pdf

Sözeri, Ceren (2011): Does Social Media Reduce ‘Corporate Media Influence’ on Journalism?: The Case of Turkish Media. Estudos em Comunicação – Communication Studies (10), 69-90. Available at: http://www.ec.ubi.pt/ec/10/pdf/EC10-2011Dez.pdf

Stolte, Yolande (2005): Preserving and Promoting Media Pluralism and Diversity in Europe: The Role of the European Union. In Brogi, E., Vodinelic, V. and Gajin, S. (eds): Developing a Harmonized Information and Communication Law in Europe. Centre for Advanced Legal Studies: Belgrade

Švob-?oki?, Nada (2011): Cultural Networks and Cultural Policies: A Missing Link. In Cvjeti?anin, B. (ed.): Networks. The Evolving Aspects of Culture in 21st Century. Culturelink/IMO: Zagreb

Švob-?oki?, Nada et al. (2008): Kultura Zaborava. Industrijalizacija Kulturnih Djelatnosti (The Culture of Oblivion. The Industrialization of Culture). Naklada Jesenski-Turk: Zagreb

Švob-?oki?, Nada (ed.) (2004): Cultural Transitions in South-Eastern Europe. Institute for International Relations: Zagreb

Van Besien, Bart (2011): ‘La responsabilité des gestionnaires de forums de discussion «non commerciaux»’ [The liability of administrators of non-commercial discussion forums]. Auteurs & Media (5-6), 562-568

Credits: kmardahl/ Creative commons

The increasing role of electronic media in news and, cialis
more generally, treatment
in content production is changing the scope and boundaries of the journalism profession and the instruments deployed to regulate the activity. Historically, journalism has primarily been self-regulated. The limits of public legislation, mainly driven by the constitutional constraints posed by the freedom of expression, have created different models of national private regulatory regimes across Europe. Media regulation is a multilevel architecture and national legal systems still play a primary role in designing rules concerning news production. Self-regulation reflects national approaches and varies according to legal and social regulatory cultures. Within the private sphere, different forms of regulation have been implemented reflecting the changing balance between the profession, the industries and the new players which have emerged after the Web revolution. The development of new media poses the following important challenges to that regulatory framework: the criteria to be used to define journalism; the distinction and the boundaries between professional and non-professional journalism; the distinction between commercial and social/not for profit content production. This essay examines these challenges looking at practice and litigation in European countries, identifying the different conflicting interests generating this litigation and the (private) regulatory responses. It will explore the differences between professional and industry regulation both within and across media: looking at the national and European or transnational regulatory scope of these regimes.

Fabrizio Cafaggi & Federica Casarosa, Research team of the European University Institute (EUI), ‘Private regulation, freedom of expression and journalism: Towards a European approach?’ EUI Working Papers, Law 2012/20. Available at: http://www.mediadem.eliamep.gr/wp-content/uploads/2010/05/WP-LAW-2012-20.pdf.

You may leave a comment with the authors.